All was about to change as his second grade teacher would constantly punish him for writing comics and openly tell him what a horrible writer he was. This does not do well for a seven year old's psyche. I don't think anyone's budding self-esteem and confidence in any area would blossom under such negative scrutiny. There was so much wrong with second grade and his hostile teacher and oppressive environment. I could go on about that and I often do. But, this post is about the success that deschooling and unschooling has brought to us.
Just yesterday, after months and months of zero writing and complete unschooling, L asked me if I would like to play a writing game. We wrote together for about 5 -10 minutes and he declared that he enjoyed writing. A lot. This was a huge breakthrough. I have put absolutely zero pressure on him about writing either with a pencil or through keyboarding. He is extremely verbose and his ability to theorize and analyze anything and everything verbally was enough for me. Comprehension was clearly not an issue. As important a skill as writing is, I knew that if we put emphasis on it, no positive outcome would result. Too much damage had been done in 2010/2011. Even last year while with a lovely and positive teacher, writing was still L's kryptonite and the only thing L would do was the minimal necessary requirement...with resistance.
So, here we are. One day after realizing that writing is not the enemy and even that, "Writing is so much fun!" The two boys and I are playing our new favorite game and then L suddenly states, "I think I am going to go write a new comic book" and off he went to his room to focus, create and WRITE. He has been writing for over a half an hour with no breaks.
I always thought he was a natural born writer but the thoughts just flow so quickly that there is no way his hand can keep up with the ideas flooding his mind. This is such a huge breakthrough in our home and since little brother like to emulate big brother, we may end up with two boys who love to write. Did I really just say that? Seriously, I am in a state of shock right now.
Deschooling is of special importance when real damage to learning has been done. I had not even realized we were still deschooling but apparently we were, in terms of writing. Deschooling really is about changing one's attitude and expectation. It is not just for kids. Parents really need to embrace deschooling for however long it takes. The reward is worth it when you see the love of learning resurface.
I am so happy for this outcome! What a blessing for your son to have such a patient and gentle mom. I am grateful my sons never went to school. My younger son still wrestled a little with self-esteem and frustration. We mostly unschooled, but did dabble in some workbook math and spelling. I think the hardest thing for him was having an older brother who seem to breathe in knowledge. I think if we could have lived on an island with only other unschoolers he might have been fine. He did go to Sunday School-which involved reading and writing. He was a late reader and even later writer, so I think he was teased a little by his public school peers. Thankfully, at 22 he seems to have found his stride, has several successful college classes under his belt, and is exploring the work world as a car salesman. Our older son-the one who breathed in knowledge began writing a novel in his teens. Also very articulate from an early age. Unfortunately, his English 1A prof. was part-time and didn't care much. Though a straight A student in all college classes prior, he got an F in English 1A, mostly because of feeling he was being forced to write, to write on topics he could care less about, etc. The good news is when he re-took the class he had an AWESOME professor-who, wait for it...used to own a comic book store!!! One of their assigned texts was Watchmen-a graphic novel. Their first writing assignment was to write about their writing thus far-good, bad, and ugly. This was very cathartic for my son. He is now working on his masters and is an excellent writer. Still not his passion, he would much rather tell you in person what he wants to say! Thanks for giving me the opportunity to share my story!
ReplyDeleteWhat a wonderful breakthrough! I cannot imagine having to fight that kind of block. Yeah for deschooling!
ReplyDeleteWe had a similar experience. Our son was basically punished for being an advanced reader. His teacher wanted the kids (in Kindergarten) to color an alphabet worksheet each day. You know the kind with a letter of the alphabet and beside the letter is an object that begins with that letter. The idea is to trace the letter and then color in the object. Well, his teacher had already gone through the entire alphabet, and when she decided to go back through and do all the letters again, he balked.
ReplyDeleteHe refused to pick up the crayon and do it. He had already done activities like that with me at home when he was 3. He tolerated doing it again the first go-through, but was ready for something more challenging by the 2nd one. The teacher started keeping him in at recess until he'd pick up that crayon and color that darned paper. After a week of that, I had had enough (this was just the last straw on the back. Like you, I could go on and on about how horrible this teacher was).
When we finally brought him home to homeschool, we also spent some time deschooling. We didn't have to do too much of it, since I had been supplementing his education at home anyway, so he was used to the learning activities and atmosphere of learning we had in our home already. It did take time, however, for him to release the post traumatic stress of dealing with some a terrible and cruel teacher. His excitement for learning took a few weeks to return, and like you I didn't push anything.
It's amazing how damaging just one adult can be to a child.
Hi Amy.
ReplyDeleteEnjoyed the deschooling writing of yours here. I am 8 weeks into no more school with my 7 yo boy Rain. He has declared he wont be writing anymore...Writing was used as a punishment by a bad old witch teacher and he was not as neat as many older kids in his class (he was put with older kids as he is bright)so feels bad about himself when he writes..
Your words give me hope that he will write some day. I am letting it just be.
However, i can;t seem to let maths just be!
i am randomly finding myself creating spontaneous mini maths lessons that are he falls for for a short time then gets annoyed with (of course)
I find it hard to trust in this area. Not keen on online rewards based maths and he isn't keen at all. He is above grade level at maths but has declared he hates it (bad boring school stuff)
He used to enjoy it before it became work at school. I enjoy it so i find it hard...
Being gifted the times table is of no interest at this point (although he knows half of it)
Anyway, encouragement to deschool is valuable for me, especially when i see your writing story.
Thanx
Dawn
https://www.facebook.com/nomoreschool2013?ref=hl
http://nomoreschool2013.wordpress.com/about/